Amity spray gives an extremely light hold/texture, so it's good for days when you want your hair to have some body and stay out of your face, but not be glued in place. American Gardens Clay is definitely a unique feel. The clay gives a pretty firm body and hold, but the rinse out is easy, maybe due to the aloe in the formula. Currently my 2 favorite products in the lineup, and it's nice to save a few bucks in a bundle like this. I have fine, fairly thick hair and both these products work well without weighing things down.