I have straight fine hair and most products make my hair fall flat or don't last all day because it eventually weighs down my hair. I typically go for clays or matte paste that have kaolin and/or Bentonite in them. Northern Lights was really good, but it was more of a loose relaxed look and my hair would eventually fall as the day progressed. American Gardens has an amazing hold that can really shape and style my hair to how I like it. My hair isn't long nor short, my front pieces of hair go a bit passed my eyes so that gives you perspective of how long it is. Applying was easy, but you definitely need some finesse and experience with clays so you don't pull out your hair. I have read reviews of people saying it was not easy to work with, but I disagree and think it is a really easy/beginner clay to work with but it is all on how you apply it and you will probably need to practice different techniques. Another bonus is that it is not drying even though it is a clay; as a matter of fact it is hydrating as the day progresses and makes my hair feel nice. I have had clays that feel like cement on my head, but I love how American Gardens makes my hair feel natural when I run through it. The scent is good, but not overbearing. I am into collecting fragrances and I appreciate the smell and how it does not interfere with what I am wearing. Overall, I think this is the best Shear Revival product for medium length straight fine hair and it is my favorite from the brand. 10/10

I see a lot of negative reviews here that all say mostly the same thing about it being extremely hard.
This is true..at first. The further down into the jar you go, the easier it gets. I’m assuming this is because of the way the product cures after being poured.
The bad thing about that is the product is very inconsistent the more you use. The top half of the jar is very dry with a high hold. The bottom half of the jar it more oily with slightly less hold.
Overall I love this product and will continue to buy more. Just wish it was more consistent.

I love the American Gardens Clay Pomade. Excellent scent. For a clay, really good hold, not overbearing.

HANDS DOWN THE BEST POMADE I’VE USED!! I’ve experimented with TONS of different brands and products throughout the years. I’ve always struggled to find that perfectly natural flow that doesn’t consistently fall down into my eyes or blow all over the place in the lightest wind. I’m a male with thicker hair that drapes down to my nose, wearing it flowed back. I love the natural look and feel this provides, all while holding every hair very firmly in place. This holds like a much greasier product, applies very easily without feeling like I’m tearing my head off, but it looks and feels like your natural hair. Absolutely blown away by this Clay Pomade and cannot recommend it enough! The smell is pleasant as well, but in no way overbearing. Performance is the name of this game.

The smell is ok 👌.

The hold is more of a medium than high hold.

The texture is great.

The ease of application is fine after emulsifying.

I think this could use more wax to make scooping it out easier? I’m no chemist, so don’t crucify me if I got that wrong.

Overall 8/10 - great score for me

FHS Clay is a 9/10

Victory crown Matte Clay 10/10