I like being able to sample different products that I've heard about online, but not having to commit to the full jar—it happens too often that I'll hear great things about a product that ends up not working with my hair type.
Northern Lights is the product I hear the most about online, and I have to say that it lives up to the hype. I was expecting a little more hold, but the fact that I can still run my hand through my hair and reshape it helps out here. I like Crystal Lake as a slightly milder alternative, too.
The American Gardens clay has a hold and texture somewhere in between the Hanz de Fuko Quicksand and Claymation products, both of which I've used and liked. I have thick hair and this did a good job of taming it without looking like I have gel in my hair.
The Loyal styling balm doesn't seem to do anything, but it smells nice. The shine that the Younger Days gel pomade leaves isn't for me, but that's why I got the sampler pack!
Overall, pretty good value (listed at $56 down from $70, there was a holiday sale taking it further down to $46, but $10 shipping (?!) and taxes brought it back up to $60). I'll take this over having barely-used jars, though.